Indiana Whiskey Holiday Gift Guide 2025

Holiday shopping can be complicated, but we’ll make it easy: whiskey makes everything better. Whether you’re buying for the purist who wants nothing but the basics, the relative who loves flavored spirits, or the friend who swears cocktails are too much effort, we’ve got a bottle that fits every personality on your list.

Here’s our ultimate Indiana Whiskey Gift Guide — 9 bottles that will keep your holidays spirited.

For the Purist : ‘Just Whiskey’ Bourbon Whiskey

Straightforward. No gimmicks. No shortcuts. Just whiskey the way it’s supposed to be. This bottle is for the friend or family member who likes things classic, clean, and uncompromised.

Pair it with: a set of heavy-bottomed rocks glasses.

For the Bold One: Silver Sweet Corn Whiskey

Raw, unfiltered, unapologetic. This unaged spirit is Indiana corn at its finest, bottled with all the boldness intact. Perfect for the adventurous drinker who’s not afraid to step outside tradition.

Pair it with: a cocktail shaker and fresh citrus for experimenting or one of our limited blue/gold shot glasses

For the Sweet Tooth: Confections of a Chocoholic

Whiskey meets rich milk chocolate. It’s indulgent, smooth, and unapologetically delicious. Great for dessert lovers, holiday party hosts, or anyone who secretly eats the last piece of fudge.

Pair it with: Geeky Goodies Marshmallows

For the Brunch Crowd: Breakfast of Degenerates

Maple + whiskey = morning made. This one is smooth, rich, and perfectly balanced — no shortcuts, just authentic flavor. It’s the gift for the brunch enthusiast who always has pancakes on the griddle.

Pair it with: The Ragamuffin cinnamon rolls

For the Fun Friend: Peaches Be Crazy

Sweet, balanced, and just a little unexpected — much like the person you’re buying it for. Raise an eyebrow at the name, then nod in approval after the first sip. Crazy? Maybe. Crazy good? Absolutely.

Pair it with: A charcuterie box from LaBelleVie

For the Spice Lover: Hoosier Sweet Heat

This cinnamon whiskey brings the fire (because the family drama wasn’t enough). It’s sweet, spicy, and perfect for hot toddies, spiked cider, or surviving another round of “constructive family feedback.”

Pair it with: a holiday mug or mulling spices for cider.

For the Host: Old Fashioned (Pre-Made Cocktail)

No mixing, no fuss — just pour over ice and you’re done. Our bottled Old Fashioned is made with real ingredients and proper proportions. The perfect gift for the host who’s already juggling 12 side dishes.

Pair it with: a set of oversized ice cube molds.

For the Rule Breaker: The Silver-Rita (Pre-Made Cocktail)

Yes, it’s a whiskey margarita. And yes, it works. Refreshing, unexpected, and surprisingly smooth, this one is for the friend who doesn’t care what purists think and just wants something fun to sip.

Pair it with: festive glassware and a bag of tortilla chips.

For the Cozy One: The Bourbon Cream

This is comfort in a glass. Velvety smooth with just the right sweetness, our Bourbon Cream Bourbon is perfect over ice, in coffee, or poured over dessert. It’s like a warm hug — with a kick.

Pair it with: local coffee from The Ragamuffin

Wrap It Up

From straight-up bourbon for the purist to bold flavors for the adventurous, Indiana Whiskey has a gift for everyone on your list. Stock up, mix and match, and give something they’ll actually be excited to unwrap this year.